https://delivery-p150664-e1601913.adobeaemcloud.com/adobe/assets/urn:aaid:aem:c80ef394-0d40-407d-bf9d-8fff132222cb/as/Brand_Images_Places-(9).avif?assetname=Brand_Images_Places%2B%289%29.jpg&originalImageWidth=2500&originalImageHeight=1665
article | 4 min read
Different process, same result? HMRC updates WHT guidance
false
aiSummary
Summarise with AI
AI summary
/content/shoosmiths/index
Summarise with AI
title
true
Modal title
medium
17B078

HMRC has replaced its concessionary treatment for withholding tax failures. We explain the stricter claims process for UK borrowers paying overseas lenders.

Published: 17 November 2026
Authors: Thomas Wilkinson & Laura Board

Summary

On 2 November, HMRC published its revised guidance on failures to withhold tax on interest payments to overseas lenders. In summary, the concessionary treatment allowing for payment of late payment interest only has been permanently withdrawn and has been replaced with a more formal and stricter process, which will inevitably be more administratively burdensome, to essentially achieve the same result.

Current withholding tax position

A UK borrower is required to withhold income tax at the basic rate of 20% from payments of UK source yearly interest to non-UK lenders.

Where there is a double tax treaty (DTT) between the UK and lender jurisdiction, it can typically be the case that relief from withholding tax (WHT) is available. In order to access such relief, the UK borrower is required to make a claim and until HMRC issues a direction that the UK borrower can pay the interest gross to the overseas lender (i.e. free from WHT), the UK borrower must continue to WHT on any interest payments made. This current process can be lengthy and provide sub optimal results for the parties involved.

Concessionary treatment

Up until 23 December 2025, HMRC operated a concessionary treatment under which, where interest was paid to an overseas lender gross of UK WHT without the necessary directions from HMRC, but the conditions for relief under the relevant DTT were met, HMRC would not seek to recover the unpaid tax from the UK borrower and would instead seek to recover only late payment interest and, if appropriate, penalties. The UK borrower would make a voluntary disclosure requesting for the concession to apply and to be assessed for late payment interest only.

This concessionary treatment made sense because ultimately the overseas lender’s jurisdiction has taxing rights over the interest pursuant to the DTT, not HMRC. There was simply an administrative failure from the UK borrower in not getting the necessary directions in place ahead of making the relevant interest payment to the overseas lender. By applying the concessionary treatment, it removed the burdensome and somewhat circular process of: (i) UK borrower having to pay the WHT to HMRC; (ii) UK borrower seeking to recover such amounts from lender; and (iii) lender having to make a repayment claim to recover this sum from HMRC.

On 23 December 2025, HMRC confirmed the concessionary treatment was under review, and its review of any voluntary disclosures would be paused during the review period.

Updated guidance

New HMRC guidance provides that, from 2 November 2026, instead of making a disclosure, UK borrowers who fail to WHT from interest payments to overseas lenders must now make a claim for treaty relief.

The claim form is lengthy and not least requires the UK borrower to include a declaration from the lender that they are beneficially entitled to the interest as well as certification of the lender’s tax residence. Whilst the onus is on the UK borrower to submit the claim, they will clearly need the lender to co-operate. In addition, a separate claim form will be required for every loan and equally for every lender.

Where HMRC is satisfied that the borrower is entitled to treaty relief, this will be given by discharging the obligation to pay the unpaid WHT or, where the relevant tax has already been paid, by making the appropriate repayment. HMRC will still look to recover late payment interest and may also consider whether a penalty is due.

The new guidance does not set out how HMRC will resolve disclosures subject to the temporary pause in processing disclosures and notes that HMRC are still considering how to deal with these. However, it does provide that any UK borrower that has an existing disclosure in relation to a failure to deduct may make a claim for treaty relief (i.e., they may use the new system).

Analysis

There were fears that HMRC might look to abolish the concessionary treatment altogether without any suitable replacement – that would have been a very disappointing outcome and one which would have been, in our view, illogical. So, whilst the new process is more formal and stricter, it preserves the spirit of the concessionary treatment going forward, and that should be welcomed.

HMRC may have been prompted to put the concessionary treatment on a more formal footing because the disclosures received were of varied quality and detail. By requiring taxpayers to complete a standardised form which is only valid when submitted correctly and with the required documentation, HMRC may consider that this will enable them to deal with WHT failures more expeditiously.

However, it is disappointing that HMRC maintain that they are still considering how to deal with historic disclosures made before 2 November 2026. Given it has been almost a year, we hoped that HMRC would have reached a position on this by now, not least because they have now reached a view on how the issue should be dealt with going forward.

Finally, whilst HMRC have maintained that the review of the concessionary treatment and the wider review of the withholding tax regime which is currently being undertaken are separate matters (see our article here for further analysis), if the withholding tax regime does move towards a ‘self-assessment’ style system, then the relevance of the concessionary treatment / updated guidance would be diminished because either a UK borrower (i) correctly determines that treaty relief is available and makes the appropriate payment to the overseas lender; or (ii) incorrectly determines that treaty relief is available and makes an incorrect payment to an overseas lender. In that scenario, the borrower is rightly liable for the UK WHT that should have been withheld.