Earn-outs can help corporate buyers and sellers agree a price in situations where a mutually acceptable valuation of the target business cannot be found. The risk is that the underlying disagreement is not resolved, but simply deferred until after completion, when the buyer controls the business, but the seller still has money at stake.
David Meisel, Partner in Shoosmiths' Corporate team, and Emma Carr, Partner in Shoosmiths' Commercial Litigation team, look at five issues worth considering before the deal is done.
Published: 20 November 2027
Authors: Emma Carr & David Meisel
Earn-outs are being used with increasing frequency as a means of bridging the valuation gap between buyer and sellers on M&A transactions. By linking part of the purchase price to performance after completion, it is not necessary for the parties to agree today what the business will ultimately prove to be worth. Earn-outs can also preserve cash for the buyer and incentivise founders or other key people to stay involved.
Our Corporate team is seeing earn-outs feature with increasing regularity in M&A transactions. In the 12 months to October 2026, approximately 31% of the M&A share sale and purchase transactions recorded in our deal data incorporated an earn-out mechanism. Our analysis shows that the earn-outs most commonly operated over a two-year period following completion, with the earn-out element of the consideration equivalent to an average of slightly in excess of 30% of the total consideration.
Once the deal completes however, the buyer may want to integrate the business into its wider group, invest for growth or change the way it operates. All perfectly legitimate commercial decisions, but they may not sit neatly with the assumptions on which the earn-out was agreed. The parties therefore need to think beyond the formula and consider how the business is actually likely to be run during the earn-out period.
As David Meisel explains, the important thing is to identify any difference in expectations early:
“When negotiating an earn-out, we need to understand what the buyer plans to do with the business and what the seller is assuming about its future performance. If those assumptions are different, it is much better to find that out while the deal is being negotiated than when the first earn-out calculation lands.”
So, what should the parties be thinking about before the earn-out is agreed?
1. What happens to the calculation when the business changes?
Modelling what the seller receives at EBITDA of £8 million rather than £10 million is relatively easy. The more useful exercise is to ask what might happen during the earn-out period to produce those numbers.
Integration into the buyer's group may mean moving customers, people or functions between businesses or allocating costs differently. The buyer may make an investment that depresses profit during the earn-out period but makes complete commercial sense over the longer term. There may be an acquisition, a disposal or a founder may leave earlier than expected.
None of those things necessarily involves anyone doing anything wrong. They can, however, materially change the earn-out.
The metric needs testing too. Revenue may look simple, but growth at the expense of margin may not be what the parties intended to reward. EBITDA brings costs and investment into play, while operational milestones can avoid some of those issues, provided it is clear when they have been met.
Worked examples are useful, but don't just model different numbers. Model a few realistic events and decisions and see what they do to the numbers.
2. How much freedom should the buyer have to run the business?
There is an obvious tension here. The seller wants protection because part of its price remains at risk, while the buyer has paid for the business and needs to be able to run it.
The answer is not necessarily a longer list of things the buyer cannot do.
Take a substantial investment which reduces EBITDA during the earn-out period but is plainly the right decision for the business. Preventing it may protect the seller's earn-out, but could make little commercial sense for the buyer or the business.
Sometimes a restriction will be appropriate. In other cases, it may make more sense to allow the buyer to act but agree how the financial effect will be treated for the purposes of the earn-out. Information or consultation rights may be enough in other circumstances.
The same issue arises where a founder stays with the business. Continuing as a director or employee does not necessarily mean having control over the decisions that affect the earn-out (and, naturally, all directors must comply with their duties to the company, whatever their individual interests). The agreement needs to reflect what influence the founder will actually have and what happens if that involvement ends earlier than expected.
The widest protection is not always the best protection. The question is what risk the parties are actually trying to address.
3. What happens if something goes wrong?
A disappointing earn-out does not necessarily mean there has been a breach. The business may simply have performed less well than expected for reasons outside of the parties’ control.
Even where there has been a breach, establishing the financial consequence can be another matter.
Suppose the buyer agreed not to make material changes to key customer contracts during the earn-out period, but then renegotiated one on seemingly less favourable terms. Establishing the breach may be relatively straightforward. Working out what the seller has lost as a result, and is legally entitled to recover, can be much harder. Would the customer have continued on the previous terms and, if so, for how long? Would volumes have remained the same? What other factors might have affected the profitability of that contract?
That can quickly become an expensive, evidentially challenging argument about what would have happened had the breach not occurred.
For Emma, that is a reason to think about the potential dispute while the deal is still being negotiated:
“Earn-out disputes are not always about someone having obviously done something wrong. Often the business has changed and several things have affected performance, leaving buyer and seller with different views about who should bear the financial consequences. Looking at the drafting through a disputes lens means asking now: if this goes wrong in two years' time, what would you need to prove, what evidence would be available and who would decide it?”
Where a particular event is reasonably anticipated, there may be a better answer than leaving one party with a damages claim. The parties might agree that particular costs are disregarded, certain revenue is treated differently or, for more fundamental events, that the earn-out accelerates.
That can give the seller more certainty about what it will receive and the buyer a clearer picture of its exposure if it takes a particular course of action which is in the parties’ contemplation.
4. What happens when it is time to pay?
A carefully negotiated earn-out is of limited value if, when the time comes, the buyer cannot pay it. If payment may be two or three years away, the seller needs to consider who will owe the money and what might happen in the meantime. A parent company guarantee, escrow or other security may be appropriate, particularly if a group reorganisation or sale is contemplated. An onward sale might instead trigger early payment of the earn-out.
Those protections need to work commercially for the buyer too. Putting the full amount into escrow, for example, may defeat one of the reasons for deferring part of the consideration in the first place.
Set-off is another area worth dealing with expressly. If the buyer has a warranty or indemnity claim when the earn-out becomes payable, the parties should be clear about whether it can withhold payment and, if so, on what basis. There is a considerable difference between allowing set-off for an established liability and allowing a buyer to withhold payment simply because a claim has been made.
The drafting should also deal with what happens to any undisputed amount and how overlapping claims are treated. The same facts could affect both the earn-out calculation and a separate claim under the sale agreement, creating a risk of double recovery if the two mechanisms are looked at in isolation.
Getting the calculation right is only part of the exercise. The parties also need to know what happens when payment falls due.
5. Will the dispute process actually work?
Independent accountants are commonly used to determine disputes over earn-out accounts. That can work well where the disagreement really is about accounting treatment or calculation but not every earn-out dispute fits neatly into that box.
Suppose the seller says the buyer diverted a major customer in breach of the sale agreement. Whether there was a breach is a contractual question and the effect on EBITDA may be an accounting or valuation question. Working out what the business would have earned if the customer had not been diverted may involve both.
If an accountant decides one issue and a court or arbitrator another, the agreement needs to be clear about where one process ends and the other begins. It should also address what happens where the issues overlap, which process takes priority and whether a decision in one is binding in the other.
Otherwise, the parties risk having a dispute about how to resolve the dispute before they get anywhere near the underlying issue.
The mechanics matter too. The buyer will usually hold much of the information needed to test the earn-out calculation. The seller needs sufficient access to that information, while the buyer needs objections to be raised within a clear timetable and with enough detail to understand what is being challenged. Access to records, objection notices and deadlines should therefore be considered as part of the dispute process, rather than administrative detail at the back of the agreement.
Where founders remain involved, an escalation or mediation stage may also be worthwhile. An earn-out dispute can do considerable damage to a working relationship which may itself be important to the continuing success of the business.
Making the earn-out work
No earn-out can cater for everything that might happen over the next two or three years, nor should it try to.
The important thing is to think through the scenarios that could realistically affect the business and agree, so far as possible, where the consequences should fall. That may mean restricting what the buyer can do, allowing it greater freedom but agreeing how that will be reflected in the earn-out, or simply accepting that a particular risk sits with one party.
The same thinking should carry through to what happens when payment falls due and how any disagreement will be resolved. An earn-out can be an effective way of bridging a valuation gap. The aim should be to make sure it does that, rather than simply moving the argument about value a couple of years down the road.
It is also important to note that the tax treatment of earn-outs may vary significantly depending on the structure that is adopted. Tax advice should be sort in advance of entering into the SPA to ensure both buyer and seller understand and are comfortable with the potential taxation impacts of the proposed earn-out.