Financial services are increasingly organised around ecosystems rather than standalone products. The Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) judgment on 17 November 2026 in Alex Neill v Sony offers a timely illustration of how established competition law may respond to that structural change.
Published: 20 November 2027
Authors: Kiran Desai
The case concerned Sony’s PlayStation ecosystem. Consumers purchase a console but subsequently buy games, subscriptions and other content within the system. The claim alleged, among other things, that Sony exercised market power over the distribution of digital PlayStation content.
The CAT rejected the proposed narrow market definition (i.e., only digital games). Importantly, it considered whether competition between rival systems (i.e., console, digital games and related products) constrained Sony’s conduct in relation to products purchased subsequently.
That approach has potentially significant relevance to financial services.
Consider the evolution of digital banking and payments. A consumer may choose a bank or fintech initially for a current account or payment card, but subsequently use the same ecosystem for foreign exchange, transfers, savings, investments and credit. Likewise, merchants may obtain acquiring, gateway, fraud-prevention and other payment services within an integrated proposition.
The competition question is therefore increasingly whether individual services should always be analysed separately, or whether competition takes place between broader financial ecosystems.
Payments also raise the related question of access. Applying the established Bronner principles, Sony distinguishes between requiring access to existing infrastructure and requiring a business effectively to redesign a proprietary system to accommodate competitors. That distinction could become increasingly relevant to digital wallets, payment functionality and APIs, although the existence or possibility of regulated open-access infrastructure presents materially different circumstances.
The judgment also highlights cross-subsidisation. Sony accepted low margins on consoles and recovered value through subsequent expenditure. Analogous models are increasingly common where accounts, payments or other financial products are offered cheaply or free, while revenue is earned elsewhere within the relationship.
Sony does not rewrite competition law. Its significance is subtler. As markets become integrated, digital and platform-based, identifying the level at which competition occurs becomes increasingly important. For financial services, the relevant competitive unit may sometimes be not the individual product, but the ecosystem within which it sits.