The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has published draft guidance clarifying investment decision-making for pension scheme trustees, which aims to provide support without placing new obligations on trustees.
Published: 20 November 2027
Authors: Rhiannon Barnsley-Bloomfield & Suzanne Burrell
What is the background to the consultation?
The guidance has been developed following calls from some parts of the pensions industry for additional clarity to support trustees (and those involved in trustee decision-making) in understanding the legal framework governing pension scheme investment, in particular trustees’ fiduciary duty. The guidance builds on the paper published by the Financial Markets Law Committee dated 6 February 2024 on Pension Fund Trustees and Fiduciary Duties.
Initially, as part of the Pension Schemes Act 2026 process, Barroness Sherlock put forward an amendment which would require the Secretary of State to issue guidance explaining certain terms used in legislation in relation to pension scheme investment and including examples to illustrate how the law applies in particular scenarios.
The amendment was rejected by the House of Lords and so did not form part of the Pension Schemes Act 2026. On 22 January 2026, the Pensions Minister confirmed that guidance would be produced which would include clarification and practical support on trustees’ ability to take account of system level risks, such as climate related risks, and the impact of investments where these affect members’ long-term outcomes.
What is the consultation?
On 5 November 2026, the DWP published a consultation seeking views on the draft guidance. In particular, the consultation seeks views on whether the draft guidance “succeeds in providing a balanced and practical explanation” of the existing framework, and asks whether any aspect would benefit from clarification, amendment, additional supporting evidence or further examples.
The guidance is intended to provide a “useful reference point” for trustees, advisers and other individuals involved in pension scheme investment decision-making. The draft guidance does not introduce new duties or alter existing legal obligations, “It is intended to reflect the law as it is”. Instead, it has been produced to provide “increased clarity” on what the law in practice requires and permits. The guidance is not statutory guidance which means that is does not carry formal legal weight and trustees do not have to explain their reasoning if they choose not to follow it.
What does the draft guidance say?
The guidance expands on the interpretation of two concepts: “best interests of members” and “financially material considerations”. Some of the points from the guidance include:
Best interests of members:
- the starting point is that the purpose of a pension scheme is to use the assets of the scheme to pay pensions over time to its members
- the “interests of members” are interests of members in their capacity as members of the pension scheme, rather than in some other capacity. Trustees could be expected to have a reasonable understanding of the composition of the membership
- in the case of a potential conflict of interest, the “best interests of members” means in the sole interest of members
- investment is not just about short-term results, but also the longer-term risk carried by the fund or the longer-term return because of the investment.
Financially material considerations:
- a consideration is financially material if it is reasonably capable of affecting risk, return, outcome or opportunity in the context of investment of the scheme and achieving the purpose of the scheme. Effects may extend to the whole scheme and its purpose
- a consideration may be financially material in some contexts but not others, and whether it is and the degree to which it is financially material can change over time. However, trustees are not required to undertake disproportionate or impractical work, but they must have a reasonable process to understand financially material considerations
- “financially material considerations” relating to an investment go beyond the level of return that may be targeted or received from an investment in the short term
- decision-making includes looking at where the world may be over time and at standards that may in due course be set. The consequences of an investment may develop or become differently understood and evaluated over time
- the law applicable to an activity may not stand still, and this may be financially material. This is not confined to English law and changes in law may be retrospective
- it is proper for pension scheme trustees to situate investments and the pension fund within the wider economy - regional, national and global
- some financially material risks and opportunities cannot be understood solely at asset level
- future costs and circumstances may be considered if and where trustees reasonably conclude that there is a credible connection between an investment decision and member retirement outcomes; and
- trustees are not expected to investigate or assess future costs and circumstances of living for members as part of every investment decision.
The guidance also expands on:
- non-financial matters and how they are capable of being relevant in investment decision-making
- how to make investment decisions and how to determine the weight given to relevant matters
- the duties of trustees in investment as they extend to stewardship
- pooled investments, master trusts, buy-in and buy-out as investment decisions
- the role of advisers, managers and other professionals in investment decision-making; and
- the impact of member views.
What are the next steps?
The consultation closes at 11:59pm on 27 January 2027. Following this, the government will consider responses before determining whether revisions to the draft guidance are required. The government expects to publish consultation responses alongside final guidance.
The guidance is not meant to require trustees undertake a “wholesale revision” of existing work or challenge approaches that trustees may have used previously. We do not expect that trustees will need to carry out any new work because of the guidance.
Trustees should ensure they understand their duties in investment decision-making and keep up to date with developments which include (i) their fiduciary duties derived from trust law; (ii) the legislative and regulatory framework including materials issued by The Pensions Regulator and (iii) developments in case law.